Welcome Guest | Sign in | Register
Women are not fit for Defense Services | Group Discussion Topics with Answers | LucentBlackBoard | LucentBlackBoard.com

Home > Group Discussion > Social Topics - Group Discussion Room

Topic Name : Women are not fit for Defense Services

Points to remember before you participate in this disuccsion:

1. Assume, you one of the member of a real group discussion.

2. Take the initiative to participate and contribute your thoughts.

3. Express your positive attitude towards providing the solution.

null - (2014-06-02 20:24:52.0)

According to me, one should never undermine a women's strength! She might be physically less strong than the opposite sex but when it comes to her emotional and intelligence quotient, she's can be ten times stronger than any man! YES that a fact! if all humans are born to live and given an equal right in every sphere, then why should the women be stereotyped, and kept behind as compared to men? Men don't work in the kitchen to help his wife or family, but when he's paid for it, he damn will do it.

Coming from a defence background myself, I know the pitfalls as well as the great things about it, and there's nothing like it.
A career in this field, especially for a woman is not only the best but the "most" respectful too! It trains her to be self dependent, self financed, disciplined etc. plus the benefits she gets which no other civilian can get is the most sought after.
Those who speak that it?s not good, and women shouldn't consider it as a career option, are, according me, small minded people who are still believing in the chicly that women are inferior !
Women when given chances climb mountain feats, solve business solutions, prepare food for 25 people, and still are able to smile and bear all these topics at the end of the day.
As the saying goes thoughts becomes words and words become action!, same can be incorporated in our lives, as we the people of India, bring about a reform through our thoughts, words and ultimately our actions.
Then it?s not far when the dream of living together in harmony become a reality

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-02 20:55:26.0)

It is not only the physical structure which comes into account for the defence forces. With a minimum prescribed structure any one has a privilege to be appointed in such forces. The main point which comes into criteria in defence is the courage to face the enemies I. E) the strength to oppose all the forces that weaken our country. Taking the right decision in right time is also an important aspect. WOMEN possess the in-birth quality of having great affection and compassion for people around them. And in our families also it is our mother who manages everything by proper planning and prompts decisions. So, when the women possess all the qualities of being in defence why do we stop them?

Our history also tells us that they have been great women leaders and warriors like Rani Lakshmi Bhai, Sarojini Naidu, Indira Gandhi, Kiran Bedi. The list continues. So they have already proved that women possess the strength of being in hard sectors. So why not defence?

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 15:55:24.0)

Hello everyone. Well, I don't think there is any problem in keeping women in the actual war. I agree that women are emotional, but then they are raised to be emotional, just the way, the guys are raised to be emotionally strong, n not panic n breakdown in front of others. Such is not the case with the girls. If a girl panics, it is always considered to b a girl-thing. And yes, I would also like to add, that women are not emotionally weak. If and when the situation arises, they can handle things equally well, as a man can. And besides, no one knows exactly how you have to react to a particular situation, unless and until you are made aware of the situations.

Any civilian, be it a guy or a girl, would panic if he or she doesn't know what he has to do during war-times or such emergencies. This is the kind of the thing soldiers are given training for. So, I don't think there is a need for gender discrimination. It is not the topic to discuss if who amongst men or women is superior. Both are equals. If women are taught to face things like men, I m sure they will do equally well.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 16:39:02.0)

Although I am totally in favour of letting woman sharing the terror of serving the front line, Let me ask a question, a very simple one. How many wars could our country win if we had all female in IAF? How successful the kargil war (fought in the icy heights) would have been if we had infantry battalion all females? How successful operation Black Tornado would have been if the NSGs were all women? How much would you trust a female over a "brother-in-arms" by your side in combat? How secure would feel your country is if all of IAF were women's?
That all , that it really matters when bullets start flying.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 18:26:49.0)

In my opinion, women?s are for fit for the defence services because now-a-days technology are always growing at high rates due to that during the wars one no need to show their strength power only instead of that he/she will make use of their will power their smartness during the war, and we all know that that will power of women?s are always comparable or even more than that of the men.

Hence women?s are fit for defence services. As we can see that women?s are taking part in sports like wrestling, cricket, races etc. Which shows their physically fit evidences for armed services as well as we know that womens have proved themselves as intellectually and mentally fit?

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 18:53:39.0)

I believe women can shoot a gun as easily as men can shoot one.
i believe a man can shit his pants out of fear emotionally as equal to that of a woman too, when the shots hits the fan, it is the individual that deals with the issue and not surely their sexual gender.

In fact, if all men in public office were to get themselves a swift kick in the nuts and replaced by all women in office, you might have far less wars around the world too.
i think women think before they act, and men act before they think.
I am a man and not slamming men by my responses simply cannot agree that sexual gender makes a better soldier for any side.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 21:15:58.0)

Hello Friends,
I believe Women are capable for defence services. If given the chance in defence field surely they will prove their mettle.
But basic problem lies in structure of our society where men are on upper tier. Women have to sacrifice their career at every phase of life. There are several hindrance at each level in their career.

1. They need parents support to learn SSC and HSC.
2. If they are able to get through HSC-SSC, For graduation they need family support and permission. Considering today's condition in India where every day we hear a Rape news it becomes difficult for family to allow their young girls to go out for education.
3. Then comes difficult phase - Marriage; To continue in their career they need husband's and in-laws support to the fullest.
4. If at all they succeed in getting through Marriage phase then comes the big one - Motherhood; now here is a battle between a women and a mother. As usual a woman has to sacrifice her career.

So It is clearly wrong to say that a women is unfit for defence career. Let her free from shackles of society and then see her full potential definitely she will be at par from men.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 21:48:43.0)

Oh I see there's a lot of hue and cry on this topic. What the hell has happened to the mentality of we Indians. There are big-big posts saying "NO" to women in defence services. Excuse me?
So Guys let me put my opinion (a brief one).
See, the thing is everyone doesn't have equal endurance, courage, determination and a heart to confront death with close quarters (be it a man or a woman) but there are some who are born with it or acquire it with time. Although girls are said to be quite delicate, but mind it, not all. There are unbeatable women in every nook and corner of the country. Although not all can be able to serve on the country frontiers, but there are some who could and will (sometimes even better than men).

You couldn't confiscate there right to do something for the nation through muscle power. What is wrong if someone who has the courage, will, potential wants to serve the country! How does gender come in between? If, they can qualify the harsh training that men undergo, then why the hell, could they be stopped from entering the defence services?

So you see of course, women are can stand shoulder-to-shoulder with men. The question is totally senseless whether women are fit for defence services or not? Anyone here has full rights to agree or disagree with my opinion (you see I don't deny your rights!) :).

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-05 22:20:05.0)

Very good evening dear friend's.

In point of view today's women is fully fit for joining the defence force. Now days a burning issue we are facing everywhere that there is need of women empowerment, yes we all are agree with this point that women should be empowered, then if we are not allowing her to join defence force that mean we are trying pulling her behind by making discrimination.

We have great example in history like rani laxmibai, sarojini naidu etc, who was already part of army. Today also if a lady can the whole nation then why defence not?

Recently CRPF has introduced first group of 30 women commando, and presently more than 1200 women are serving in Indian Army.

If we look toward foreign nations recently us has also granted permission to join ground combat units to women, not only that in Pakistan, where women is not so empowered more than 4000 serving women are a part of defence. From 1947 they are allowing women to join army then what we are waiting for?

So lastly I want to say yes today's women having potential to join army, so we have to encourage them to join defence. Jai hind.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

null - (2014-06-06 11:41:25.0)

I do not agree for this,

Firstly women are the powerful source in this modern organisation with whose help each person can learn different skills. Secondly, women can handle the most difficult tasks if she serves with perfection in defence services. Thirdly, women can be of great help to the country due to their strong will power, self-motivational power, hard-work, optimistic attitude, and adaptable attitude.

Loading...

Rate this:   +0   Like      DisLike  - 0

Speak Your Mind ::

Name:

Loading...




Partner Sites
LucentBlackBoard.com                  SoftLucent.com                  LucentJobs.com
All rights reserved 2012-2015 SoftLucent.